Below is the current general news regarding Gilmore, Idaho:
Gunfire on Limestone Avenue: Incident Shakes Quiet Gilmore Community
Gilmore, Idaho – April 26, 2025
A rare disturbance disrupted the quiet of Gilmore on Saturday afternoon when gunfire was reported along Limestone Avenue, prompting a swift and heavy response from the Lemhi County Sheriff’s Office.
According to witnesses, at least one gunshot rang out within the townsite. Sheriff John Bennett, accompanied by three to four deputies in patrol trucks, quickly responded to the scene. Initial reports suggest that local resident John Mathews allegedly discharged a firearm for reasons that remain unclear.
In a tense moment, another resident reportedly emerged from his cabin with a gun drawn and pointed toward Mathews. Fortunately, no injuries were reported.
An ambulance was dispatched from the nearby highway but remained staged at the Gilmore turnoff until deputies confirmed the scene was secure. Once it was clear no medical assistance was needed, the ambulance departed without incident.
Authorities took John Mathews into custody, and he was reportedly transported to the Lemhi County Jail. Further details, including any formal charges, are expected once the case appears on the public repository website.
Residents described the law enforcement presence as significant for the small town, with at least four sheriff’s vehicles on-site — including one unmarked white truck.
UPDATE: On 4/28/25 the Idaho repository was updated, and John Mathews is charged with “Aggravated Assault (b) Great Bodily Harm”, which is a felony.
This story will be updated as more information becomes available.
Gilmore Hosts Its First-Ever “Gilmore Days” Celebration in August 2024
Gilmore, Idaho – August, 2024
The first ever “Gilmore Days” was held in August of 2024!
EPA/IDEQ Related News:
For the latest information and updates related to the EPA Superfund, please visit our dedicated [EPA Superfund page].